26 February 1990
Steve Barton (Phantom), Rebecca Luker (Christine), Gary Lindemann (u/s Raoul)
24 November 1990
Jeff Keller (u/s), Rebecca Luker, Kevin Gray
15 February 2002
Howard McGillin, Sarah Pfisterer, Michael Shawn Lewis
15 May 2007
Gary Mauer, Jennifer Hope Wills, Michael Shawn Lewis, Janet Saia (u/s), George Lee Andrews, David Cryer, Marilyn Caskey, Jimmy Smagula (u/s)
11 February 2012
Hugh Panaro, Trista Moldovan, Kyle Barisich
8 March 2013
Paul Schaefer (u/s), Samantha Hill, Jeremy Stolle (u/s), Michele McConnell, Richard Poole (u/s), Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein, Scott Mikita (u/s), Greg Mills (u/s)
9 March 2013 Matinee
Jeremy Stolle (u/s), Samantha Hill, Greg Mills (u/s), Michele McConnell, Richard Poole (u/s), Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein, Scott Mikita (u/s)
9 March 2013 Evening
Paul Schaefer (u/s), Samantha Hill, Greg Mills (u/s), Michele McConnell, Richard Poole (u/s), Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein, Scott Mikita (u/s)
15 March 2013
Hugh Panaro, Samantha Hill, Kyle Barisich
26 August 2013
Hugh Panaro, Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays, Michele McConnell, Laird Mackintosh, Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein
Hugh Panaro’s first back from his vacation, as well as Jeremy Hays and Laird Mackintosh’s first in the role
7 August 2014
Norm Lewis (Phantom of the Opera), Sierra Boggess (Christine), Jeremy Hays (Raoul), Laird Mackintosh (Andre), Tim Jerome (Firmin), Cristin J Hubbard (Madame Giry), Deanna Doyle (u/s Meg Giry), Michele McConnell (Carlotta), Christian Sebek (Piangi), Carrington Vilmont, Bronson Norris Murphy, Nathan patrick Morgan, Kenneth Kantor, Richard Poole, Scott Mikita, Jeremy Stolle, Anton Harrison LaMon* (slave master), James Zander, Emily Harvey, Andrew Drost, Lynne Abeles, Rebecca Robbins* (wardrobe mistress/confidante), Arlo Hill* (marksman), Elizabeth Welch, Rebecca Robbins, Heather Hill, Jessica Bishop, Jessy Hendrickson, Gianna Loungway, Maria Phegan, Jessica Radetsky, Carly Blake Sebouhian
10 June 2014
Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Sierra Boggess, Jeremy Hays
22 September 2014
Norm Lewis, Kaley Ann Voorhees, Jeremy Hays
13 December 2014
Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays, Ellen Harvey, Michele McConnell, Christian Sebek
29 December 2014
Norm Lewis, Kaley Ann Voorhees, Jeremy Hays
1 January 2015
Norm Lewis (The Phantom), Julia Udine (Christine), Jeremy Hays (Raoul), Lynne Abeles (alt. Carlotta), M. Andre (Laird Mackintosh), Carrington Vilmont (u/s M. Firmin), Linda Balgord (Mme. Giry), Christian Sebek (Piangi), Kara Klein (Meg Giry)Greg Mills (swing Auctioneer, Don Attilio), Scott Mikita (swing M. Lefevre, Firechief, Jeweler), Janet Saia (swing Spanish Lady), Polly Baird (swing Ballet Dancer)
9 June 2016
Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Rachel Eskenazi-Gold, Jeremy Hays, Craig Bennett, Richard Poole (u/s), Michele McConnell, John Easterlin, Rebecca Eichenberger, Kara Klein
8 September 2016
Ali Ewoldt, Jordan Donica, Laird Mackintosh, Craig Bennett, Michele McConnell, Rebecca Eichenberger, John Easterlin, Kara Klein, Marni Raab, Scott Mikita, Carrington Vilmont, Jim Witzer, Ted Keegan, Kenneth Kantor, Jacob Keith Watson, Jeremy Stolle, Nicholas Cunningham, Justin Peck, Kaley Ann Vorhees, James Barbour
Steve Barton (Phantom), Rebecca Luker (Christine), Gary Lindemann (u/s Raoul)
24 November 1990
Jeff Keller (u/s), Rebecca Luker, Kevin Gray
15 February 2002
Howard McGillin, Sarah Pfisterer, Michael Shawn Lewis
15 May 2007
Gary Mauer, Jennifer Hope Wills, Michael Shawn Lewis, Janet Saia (u/s), George Lee Andrews, David Cryer, Marilyn Caskey, Jimmy Smagula (u/s)
11 February 2012
Hugh Panaro, Trista Moldovan, Kyle Barisich
8 March 2013
Paul Schaefer (u/s), Samantha Hill, Jeremy Stolle (u/s), Michele McConnell, Richard Poole (u/s), Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein, Scott Mikita (u/s), Greg Mills (u/s)
9 March 2013 Matinee
Jeremy Stolle (u/s), Samantha Hill, Greg Mills (u/s), Michele McConnell, Richard Poole (u/s), Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein, Scott Mikita (u/s)
9 March 2013 Evening
Paul Schaefer (u/s), Samantha Hill, Greg Mills (u/s), Michele McConnell, Richard Poole (u/s), Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein, Scott Mikita (u/s)
15 March 2013
Hugh Panaro, Samantha Hill, Kyle Barisich
26 August 2013
Hugh Panaro, Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays, Michele McConnell, Laird Mackintosh, Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein
Hugh Panaro’s first back from his vacation, as well as Jeremy Hays and Laird Mackintosh’s first in the role
7 August 2014
Norm Lewis (Phantom of the Opera), Sierra Boggess (Christine), Jeremy Hays (Raoul), Laird Mackintosh (Andre), Tim Jerome (Firmin), Cristin J Hubbard (Madame Giry), Deanna Doyle (u/s Meg Giry), Michele McConnell (Carlotta), Christian Sebek (Piangi), Carrington Vilmont, Bronson Norris Murphy, Nathan patrick Morgan, Kenneth Kantor, Richard Poole, Scott Mikita, Jeremy Stolle, Anton Harrison LaMon* (slave master), James Zander, Emily Harvey, Andrew Drost, Lynne Abeles, Rebecca Robbins* (wardrobe mistress/confidante), Arlo Hill* (marksman), Elizabeth Welch, Rebecca Robbins, Heather Hill, Jessica Bishop, Jessy Hendrickson, Gianna Loungway, Maria Phegan, Jessica Radetsky, Carly Blake Sebouhian
10 June 2014
Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Sierra Boggess, Jeremy Hays
22 September 2014
Norm Lewis, Kaley Ann Voorhees, Jeremy Hays
13 December 2014
Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays, Ellen Harvey, Michele McConnell, Christian Sebek
29 December 2014
Norm Lewis, Kaley Ann Voorhees, Jeremy Hays
1 January 2015
Norm Lewis (The Phantom), Julia Udine (Christine), Jeremy Hays (Raoul), Lynne Abeles (alt. Carlotta), M. Andre (Laird Mackintosh), Carrington Vilmont (u/s M. Firmin), Linda Balgord (Mme. Giry), Christian Sebek (Piangi), Kara Klein (Meg Giry)Greg Mills (swing Auctioneer, Don Attilio), Scott Mikita (swing M. Lefevre, Firechief, Jeweler), Janet Saia (swing Spanish Lady), Polly Baird (swing Ballet Dancer)
9 June 2016
Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Rachel Eskenazi-Gold, Jeremy Hays, Craig Bennett, Richard Poole (u/s), Michele McConnell, John Easterlin, Rebecca Eichenberger, Kara Klein
8 September 2016
Ali Ewoldt, Jordan Donica, Laird Mackintosh, Craig Bennett, Michele McConnell, Rebecca Eichenberger, John Easterlin, Kara Klein, Marni Raab, Scott Mikita, Carrington Vilmont, Jim Witzer, Ted Keegan, Kenneth Kantor, Jacob Keith Watson, Jeremy Stolle, Nicholas Cunningham, Justin Peck, Kaley Ann Vorhees, James Barbour